11AM - 8PM




31 East Main Street
Fredonia, NY


Reservations Suggested!

About Us


Founded in 2006 in a farmhouse in South Dayton, New York


 The Mustard Seed Restaurant  has its roots in good food, faith, and friendship.  Nettie’s vision of creating a restaurant where people could come together for fresh, home-cooked meals, regardless of dietary restriction or personal tastes, turned into a gathering space for many across Western New York. Bob and

Laurie Scudder and Scott and Ashley Emser became patrons of the restaurant and fast friends with Nettie, embracing the restaurant’s vision of faith and friends around the table, as well as giving back to the community at large.


When the opportunity arose to bring this vision to life in Fredonia, the Scudders and the Emsers eagerly jumped at the chance to bring the unique flavor of The Mustard Seed to a new location in downtown  Fredonia.  Join The Mustard Seed Restaurant at our new location, the former Fredonia Hardware building,
to continue the conversations and friendships over fish and sandwiches, rather than nuts and bolts!

Our premise for opening this business was to create a palate that gave back to the very community that supports it.
At the end of the day,we want the offer the same environment and food choices for you, that we want for our families.


Come Visit Us At Our New Location in Fredonia!


31 East Main Street
Fredonia, NY 14063


Phone: 716-988-3800


Our Hours:


Thursday: 11am - 8pm

Friday: 11am - 8pm

Saturday: 11am - 8pm

Copyright 2019. The Mustardseed Restaurant. All Rights Reserved.

Web Design 2019 by Grandin Graphics.